Catching Fire Tops Fan Rankings as New Prequel Opens
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Entertainment
- Film
- Hunger Games
Catching Fire tops Yahoo's ranking of all five Hunger Games films; Songbirds & Snakes ranks last as Sunrise on the Reaping opens to mixed scores.
The franchise's best and worst, by the numbers
Yahoo Entertainment compiled rankings from Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic and IMDb to determine which Hunger Games movie is considered the best overall, using critics' scores for the first two platforms and user ratings for IMDb.
The result: the second original film, The Hunger Games: Catching Fire, came out on top across all three rankings, with a particularly impressive Rotten Tomatoes critics' score. The first film released, The Hunger Games, ranked second.
The two Mockingjay films placed third and fourth, with Part 2 beating Part 1 only on Metacritic. That leaves The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes as the worst-rated of the five, dragged down by its Rotten Tomatoes and Metacritic scores even though its IMDb rating matched both Mockingjay films.
A new prequel arrives with mixed early numbers
The second prequel and sixth film overall, Sunrise on the Reaping, opened in theaters on November 20, 2026, telling the origin story of Haymitch Abernathy.
Yahoo notes it is not included in the best-to-worst ranking because it has just been released, but early scores suggest a mixed response: 67% on Rotten Tomatoes and 55% on Metacritic.
According to NPR, the film follows 16-year-old Abernathy (Joseph Zada), born on reaping day and selected as tribute for the 50th anniversary Games, which reap 48 tributes in total, with Whitney Peak as Lenore Dove Baird and Jesse Plemons as Plutarch Heavensbee.
NPR's verdict: sunset for a once-edgy franchise
NPR's review, by Candice Lim, argues that Sunrise on the Reaping feels like sunset for the franchise, saying the once edgy, strong and highly political series is starting to lose steam.
The reviewer criticizes the film for not convincingly showing how the physically outmatched Haymitch won his Games, and says the shock factor of political violence that drove Hunger Games fever 14 years ago may have expired.
Still, NPR praises the supporting cast as an Easter egg hunt of favorites: Elle Fanning shines as a young Effie Trinket, Kieran Culkin delivers a sharply-tuned Caesar Flickerman, and Billy Porter, Iris Apatow and Maya Hawke make brief appearances.
Box office history and what comes next
The commercial stakes remain high even as critical consensus frays.
Yahoo reports the first film grossed a record-breaking $152.5 million in its opening weekend, at the time the biggest opening ever for a non-sequel and for a movie not released in summer, and that every installment made plenty of money, with even Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes, considered a modest win, earning over three times its budget.
NPR reports Ballad had the lowest box office earnings of the series and is the only film without Jennifer Lawrence, who briefly appears alongside Josh Hutcherson and Woody Harrelson in Sunrise on the Reaping.
With all five of Suzanne Collins' novels now adapted, NPR suggests the franchise could end here, though another ride would recast Effie Trinket.