Gillis Reveals SNL Never Pre-Approves His Monologues
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Comedy
- Saturday Night Live
- Shane Gillis
- Stand Up Comedy
Shane Gillis says SNL never vetted his controversial Oct. 10 monologue, and this time he deleted his social media immediately as the backlash landed.
What Happened: Gillis Finally Wades Into the Discourse
Shane Gillis broke more than a month of public silence on his controversial Oct. 10 'Saturday Night Live' monologue during a Nov. 13 appearance on The Joe Rogan Experience.
The joke in question found the three-time host riffing that he 'didn't know women just dressed like whores now' while commenting on women's gym shorts.
In the podcast conversation, Gillis explained that SNL never signed off on his material, telling Rogan's co-hosts that the show 'could shut it down' but that working comics write their own sets rather than hand them in for approval.
According to Billboard, the appearance came just hours before a wave of fresh coverage of the backlash cycle.
Why It's Surprising: A 'Solid C Minus' With 'No Controversy'
The most quotable reveal, reported by Entertainment Weekly via Yahoo News UK and AOL, is Gillis's own self-assessment: he claims he warned SNL staff ahead of the show that the set was mediocre but harmless. 'The funniest part was, they were like, "What's going on with the monologue?"
And I was like, "It's not great, but I don't say anything bad,"' he recalled, adding, 'Fellas, I'm giving you a solid C minus of a monologue, but I promise there's no controversy. I'm calling myself fat for f—ing 10 minutes.'
For readers of comedy, the surprise is procedural: the biggest monologue controversy of the season passed through a vetting process that, per Gillis, essentially didn't exist for him.
The Video That Sparked the Celebrity Backlash
The backlash grew after Dan Levy posted a response video on Instagram in which, as Billboard reports, he argued that 'women wearing short shorts at the gym does not make them whores; it makes the men calling them whores misogynists.'
Jewel, Lisa Loeb and Kristin Chenoweth voiced support for Levy in the comments, Flavor Flav backed his criticism, and Maggie Baird called the joke 'actually dangerous for women,' per Billboard.
Entertainment Weekly's reporting adds that SNL alums Cecily Strong and Ego Nwodim also criticized the bit, while Inde Navarrette — host of the Halloween episode weeks later — took a dig at Gillis in her own opening monologue.
The Climate, the Defenders and Gillis's New Playbook
Gillis attributed the intensity of the response to the moment rather than the joke itself, telling Rogan it 'obviously had a lot to do with the climate' and clarifying, 'For the record, [I] don't have a problem with' women's gym attire.
Rogan, whose show was released Nov. 13, argued the bit was simply 'a fun thing to say' and that 'this is a weird time where everyone's just looking to get upset,' Entertainment Weekly reports. On the other side, David Spade, Dana Carvey and Jimmy Carr came to Gillis's defense.
Notably, Gillis says his crisis strategy changed: 'This time, I just deleted everything immediately' — unlike 2019, when he says he kept his social media up and stewed.
The Stakes: A Complicated History With SNL
The context gives the dispute extra weight. As Billboard notes, Gillis was announced as an SNL cast member in 2019 but was let go before ever making his debut after past podcast comments resurfaced and sparked controversy, according to The Hollywood Reporter's reporting cited by the outlet.
Entertainment Weekly's account says the 2019 firing followed clips resurfacing of him making racist and homophobic jokes on a podcast, and that he later returned as a guest host — now a three-time one.
That history is why the monologue landed differently for audiences, and why Navarrette's on-air dig and the alum criticism kept the story alive for weeks.
What Comes Next: Gillis Claims He Isn't Watching
Where the story goes from here is, per Gillis himself, largely off his radar.
He told Rogan that he doesn't 'really know' how other comedians have been responding amid the backlash, and insists he has moved past the discourse that dominated comedy Twitter and late-night chatter for a month, Entertainment Weekly reports.
With no indication that SNL will change how it handles comedian-written monologues, the practical takeaway for fans is the window Gillis opened into the show's process — hosts who write their own sets perform them essentially unvetted, and the fallout lands entirely on them.
Whether that becomes standard operating defense for future controversial monologues is the open question this episode leaves behind.
Sources
- billboard.com › Shane Gillis Addresses 'SNL' Monologue Backlash: 'A Lot to Do With the Climate'
- aol.com › Shane Gillis promised 'no controversy' in 'SNL' monologue ahead of backlash to joke about women's gym attire
- uk.news.yahoo.com › Shane Gillis promised 'no controversy' in 'SNL' monologue ahead of backlash