Federal Judge Holds ICE in Contempt Over Instant Re-Arrests
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- US News
- Immigration
- Ice
- Colorado
- Courts
A Colorado federal judge held ICE in contempt for re-detaining immigrants minutes after court-ordered release, calling the practice a mockery.
Judge Finds ICE in Contempt in Colorado
US District Judge Charlotte Sweeney ruled Wednesday that ICE officials in Colorado were in contempt of court for an internal practice of immediately re-detaining immigrants who had just been ordered released.
Writing in a 15-page ruling, she stated that ICE's new policy of re-detaining petitioners right after release made a mockery of court orders mandating their immediate release, adding that all court orders must be complied with promptly and that this was neither a novel nor complex statement to comprehend.
At Least 18 Caught in the Cycle
According to CPR News, the news division of Colorado Public Radio, at least 18 people in Colorado have been held in detention longer than they should have been or were re-arrested within minutes of a judge-ordered release in the past six weeks.
Immigration attorneys told the outlet the true number is likely higher because some immigrants represented themselves in court.
Advocates describe a pattern that has grown noticeable in recent months: sometimes a person is re-arrested days after release, sometimes without even leaving the detention facility, often in violation of a federal court order.
Testimony That Stunned the Court
Per Colorado Public Radio, ICE officials testifying under oath appeared uncertain about who was in charge and what rules applied.
Nichole Black, assistant field office director for ICE's Enforcement and Removal Operations, told the judge she received a direct order from her supervisor that she could re-detain immigrants with some type of criminality, and said she believed it was permissible to escort someone to a public area and immediately re-detain them despite a contrary court order.
Her supervisor, Nathan Rasper, said he understood he was obligated to make lawful arrests and had heard of a re-arrest policy in Minnesota. Sweeney wrote that such behavior should, and in the court's opinion must, shock any reader.
No Penalty Yet, But a Warning
The contempt ruling stopped short of fines or other sanctions. Sweeney explained that the court declined to take further action because Rasper testified he had stopped re-arresting people ordered released, which she said cured the contempt.
She nonetheless framed the ruling as a warning that any renewed violations could reopen the matter, invoking the principle that no man is above the law.
The Trump administration maintains its immigration actions aim to improve domestic security and comply with the law; ICE and the Department of Homeland Security did not immediately respond to requests for comment on the ruling.
With Democrats now holding House and Senate majorities after the midterms, they aim to hold the administration accountable for its immigration policies.