McDonald's Sued Over AI Pricing Tool in Class Action

A proposed class action alleges McDonald's AI pricing tool amounts to algorithmic price-fixing across 14,000 US restaurants.

Read as article

McDonald's Sued Over AI Pricing Tool in Class Action

By @sharedot · · 8 pages

  • Food
  • Mcdonalds
  • Antitrust
  • AI Pricing

A proposed class action alleges McDonald's AI pricing tool amounts to algorithmic price-fixing across 14,000 US restaurants.

The Lawsuit: 'Algorithmic Price-Fixing'

McDonald's is facing a proposed nationwide class action filed October 2 in federal court in Chicago by Michael Thomas of DeKalb, Illinois, over the company's alleged use of an AI-enhanced pricing tool across its independently owned franchises, according to The Guardian and USA Today. The complaint says the tool lets franchise locations exchange nonpublic price and sales data, which prosecutors argue violates antitrust law and has unfairly inflated menu prices for Americans. In its own language, the suit calls the system an "information-sharing pricing platform" drawing on millions of daily transactions, producing "algorithmic price-fixing aimed at customers who are already stretched thin."

Why It's a First for Fast Food

What makes this case unusual is the theory itself: because McDonald's does not grant franchisees exclusive territories, L'Express Franchise reports that two restaurants in the same area can be owned by different operators selling to the same customers — making them horizontal competitors. Under the plaintiffs' antitrust theory, a shared AI system recommending prices across a network of nominally independent competitors can constitute illegal price-fixing even without explicit agreements between them. A recent Reuters investigation, cited by The Guardian, reported that some franchise owners were pressured by the company to use the AI tools and record deviations from recommendations; McDonald's called that characterization "speculative and uninformed."

The Evidence: Prices Up 40%

According to a 2024 McDonald's fact sheet, the average price of a menu item rose about 40% between 2019 and 2024, and Claim Depot reports the lawsuit contends that increase is related to the pricing tool's rollout. Thomas, described as a "price conscious" regular, noticed his usual order — a Quarter Pounder with cheese, fries and a Coke — varied even within his DeKalb neighborhood. Claim Depot also reports the tool allegedly suggests raising an item's price once at least 30% of stores have already done so, and that McDonald's has required franchisees to use approved pricing tools since January 2026 while tracking owners who depart from recommendations.

'AI Does Not Set the Price of a Big Mac'

McDonald's has flatly denied the allegations, telling reporters the "complaint is filled with inaccuracies and we will vigorously defend against this lawsuit." "AI does not set the price of a Big Mac or any other menu item," the company said in a statement reported by USA Today, adding that franchisees make their own pricing decisions and that optional tools "do not automate, coordinate or fix pricing in any way." A company spokesman told the Associated Press, "All we do is provide the context of what's going on. We don't have any way to affect the menu pricing in a restaurant."

The Stakes for Franchise Fast Food

The stakes extend far beyond one burger chain. L'Express Franchise notes a parallel wave of lawsuits has targeted landlords and hotel groups using shared revenue-management software under a similar theory, and if courts accept that framing here, it would reach any QSR or retail franchise using a system-wide pricing tool. CEO Chris Kempczinski acknowledged in August that only 60% of US restaurants were offering the proposed 10-item menu under $3, saying "it requires conversations with franchisees" — a quote the complaint uses to argue the company pressures franchisees while calling the tool optional. Experts cited by The Guardian say at least 90 pieces of legislation were filed this year to push back against algorithmic price-fixing.

What Happens Next

The case, Thomas v. McDonald's USA, LLC et al., remains at the complaint stage in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, and McDonald's has not yet filed a formal response in court, L'Express Franchise reports. Thomas is asking a judge to certify the class so potentially millions of McDonald's customers nationwide can join, seek damages and prevent the company from enforcing agreements that restrict competition. If it proceeds, discovery could surface internal documentation about how the pricing tool works — and franchise attorneys across the QSR sector will be watching closely.

Sources

  1. theguardian.com › McDonald's sued for allegedly using AI tool to determine pricing for franchises
  2. usatoday.com › McDonald's sued over alleged AI-powered menu price-fixing
  3. lexpress-franchise.com › McDonald's Faces Class Action Over AI Pricing Tool Deployed Across Its Franchise Network
  4. claimdepot.com › McDonald's class action alleges company used AI to fix franchise menu prices
  5. wmtv15news.com › McDonald's sued over AI tool that recommends prices to US franchisees

More on Food