Slotkin Fires Back at DOJ's Reitz Over 'Sham' Probe
By @sharedot · · 7 pages
- Politics
- Justice Department
- Elissa Slotkin
- Free Speech
Sen. Elissa Slotkin rejected a Texas U.S. attorney's threat to investigate her oversight remarks as baseless, telling Trump and Reitz: 'Bring it on.'
What happened: A senator calls a federal probe 'baseless'
Sen. Elissa Slotkin, D-Mich., sent a letter Wednesday to Aaron Reitz, the Trump-appointed U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of Texas, rejecting his threat to investigate her comments about congressional oversight.
According to NBC News, Reitz had posted letters on social media to five Democratic members of Congress — Slotkin, Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Richard Blumenthal and Adam Schiff, and Rep. Robert Garcia — suggesting her remarks about oversight acting as a "deterrence message" could amount to a criminal civil rights offense.
Slotkin wrote that the Constitution's Speech or Debate clause bars prosecution of legislators for legislative acts, demanded he withdraw the letter, and said she would "not participate in his sham investigation."
Why it is surprising: A prosecutor staking his name on speech
The confrontation is unusual on several fronts.
Reitz, 39, a former chief of staff to Sen. Ted Cruz who placed fourth in a Republican primary for Texas attorney general before taking the U.S. attorney post this summer, chose to publicize the letters on X rather than deliver them privately — a move Slotkin said violates Justice Department policy and signals "publicity and your political ambitions" over legitimate inquiry.
Legal experts have scrutinized the letters, NBC News reports. Reitz told NBC News he was "not interested in chilling free speech," even as Slotkin's attorney, Preet Bharara, had already cautioned Attorney General Todd Blanche against pursuing Trump's public instruction to investigate her speech.
The evidence: DOJ's own leadership undercut the threat
The strongest evidence against the probe comes from within the administration itself.
According to NBC News, Attorney General Todd Blanche has conceded that Slotkin's words alone were "absolutely not a crime" and said at a press conference last week that there were "no ongoing criminal investigations into words that incoming senators or congressmen have said."
Slotkin, on X per Newsweek, framed her defiance around precedent: "Freedom of speech is a fundamental American value, and we already beat Jeanine Pirro when she tried this before." Allies of D.C.
U.S. Attorney Jeanine Pirro tried to indict Slotkin and five other Democrats over a video urging service members not to obey unlawful orders, but federal grand jurors unanimously rejected that indictment attempt.
The stakes: Oversight, the First Amendment and 2027 Congress
The fight lands at the intersection of two constitutional duties Slotkin invoked: the First Amendment's free speech guarantee and the Senate's oversight responsibility, which she called "an important constitutional responsibility."
Slotkin said Reitz's threats are "frivolous and a violation of your ethical duties as an attorney," and that she "reserve[s] all rights to take appropriate actions."
What comes next: 'Bring it on'
Slotkin's public posture — "So to President Trump and Mr. Reitz I say: Bring it on," per Newsweek — leaves little room for quiet resolution.
The standoff sets up a likely test of the Speech or Debate clause in the courts, and of whether a U.S. attorney can sustain an investigation that the attorney general has publicly dismissed as pointless. For now, both sides appear dug in.