Sotheby's Fights $180M Van Gogh Claim With 1936 Sale Data
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Art
- Restitution
- Auctions
- Nazi Era Art
Sotheby's says dealer archives show the Fischer family's van Gogh sold voluntarily at a strong 1936 price as the heirs press a Nazi-era duress claim.
Sotheby's Answers the Heirs With Archives
With *Châtaigniers en fleurs* (1890) due to go under the hammer Wednesday at roughly $180 million, Sotheby's has stopped defending the sale only on process and started defending it on price.
The house told ARTnews that archives of dealer Paul Cassirer confirm the painting sold for 68,000 Swiss francs — about $22,000 — in June 1936, which Sotheby's considers a strong price for a van Gogh at the time.
As a benchmark, ARTnews notes that *Verger avec cyprès* sold at Parke-Bernet in 1935 for $15,000 before fetching $117.2 million at Christie's in 2022. Lawyer Luke Nikas says the painting went to an independent buyer at fair market value.
Why a 'Good Price' Doesn't End the Argument
The heirs' lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, has raised the bar beyond price: per an email seen by the New York Times and quoted by ARTnews, he demanded proof the family received fair market value *and* would have sold even if the Nazis had never come to power — 'Otherwise,' he wrote, 'no auction may take place.'
dutchnews.nl reports that international guidelines backed by the Netherlands and the United States say sales made under financial pressure from Nazi persecution can count as involuntary, though the guidelines are not legally binding.
Sotheby's says its research has not established the painting was sold under duress and that it is in talks with the heirs.
The Legal Pendulum Just Swung Toward Claimants
ARTnews reports that in April, Congress amended the HEAR Act to eliminate *laches*, the defense letting courts toss restitution claims heirs waited too long to bring.
New York art lawyer Judd Grossman, not involved in the dispute, told ARTnews the pendulum has 'swung dramatically in favor of claimants' and predicts more last-minute claims.
Sotheby's lawyer Luke Nikas counters that Congress removed only the delay defense, leaving the legal test for duress untouched — a test he believes the 1936 sale fails, citing rulings like *Bennigson v.
Guggenheim*, where a 2024 New York judge held Nazi-persecution economic pressure wasn't enough when the buyer hadn't contributed to it.
The Provenance Puzzle: Two Cézannes Tell a Different Story
According to ARTnews, the van Gogh was placed with Cassirer's Amsterdam gallery in 1932 or 1933 — outside Nazi control — alongside two Cézannes, and stayed on consignment nearly three years before the sale. The family's postwar recovery brochure, as Nikas describes it, does not list the van Gogh.
One Cézanne hangs at Harvard Art Museums without a claim; the other sold at Christie's in 2017 for almost $6 million, with heir Gisela Bermann Fischer telling Christie's in 2007 she wouldn't oppose that sale — while, as reported by the Times, reserving the right to challenge other works she believed were sold under duress.
Sotheby's says it never saw that confidential letter.
What's at Stake: A Record, a Guarantee, a Collection
The van Gogh is the star lot of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, whose 12 Impressionist and Post-Impressionist works are expected by Ynetnews to bring around $450 million of New York's roughly $2.4 billion auction week.
Sotheby's has guaranteed the van Gogh — amount undisclosed, per ARTnews — which would beat the artist's $117.2 million auction record set at Christie's in 2022, a figure dutchnews.nl also cites.
dutchnews.nl adds the painting has not been shown publicly since 1964 and was bought by Carlos Pedro and Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier in 1975. As of Monday, Sotheby's had not said whether the lot stays in the sale.
What Comes Next: Dialogue Before Wednesday
The family of late sugar magnate Carlos Pedro Blaquier said in a statement to ARTnews that while available information has not established a sale under duress, it 'welcomes constructive dialogue with the Fischer heirs and supports efforts to reach a mutually satisfactory resolution.'
Ynetnews notes Schnabel asked Sotheby's to prove a counterfactual from 90 years ago — that the family would have sold regardless of the Nazis — which may be difficult to establish.