Clancy Jury Notes Fuel Double-Jeopardy Plea to SJC
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- True Crime
- Lindsay Clancy
- Massachusetts Courts
- Double Jeopardy
Clancy's lawyers asked Massachusetts' highest court to block his second murder trial, citing jury notes and an uninvestigated holdout juror.
What Happened: The Petition to the SJC
On Nov. 16, attorneys Marty Weinberg, Michael Pabian and Kevin Reddington filed a petition with the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court asking it to review Judge William Sullivan's rulings and decide whether a second trial would violate Clancy's protection against double jeopardy.
The filing came the same day Sullivan set the retrial for March 29, 2027, after prosecutors signaled they were ready to pick a jury trial date on first-degree murder charges. A hearing on trial logistics is set for Dec. 30, with a pretrial conference on Feb. 18.
Why It's Surprising: The Jury Notes
The surprise is what the newly revealed jury notes actually said. The foreperson's first note to Sullivan on Sept. 3 read: "A member of the jury is unable to follow the instructions regarding reasonable doubt. How should we proceed?"
A second note stated that a juror "has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states." The defense reads those notes as showing an 11-1 split, with one juror refusing to return a not guilty verdict despite acknowledging reasonable doubt.
Prosecutors countered that the notes may reflect an ordinary disagreement about applying the law.
The Evidence: Sidebar Transcripts Surface
Los Angeles Magazine obtained previously private sidebar transcripts through a Supreme Judicial Court request, revealing tense exchanges between Reddington and Sullivan over how the court handled the holdout juror.
"We're trying the case at the sidebar. It's not right," Reddington said, adding that Clancy "is entitled to know what's going on." Sullivan replied, "Well, I don't think it stinks."
Sullivan ultimately questioned each juror individually and all said they could follow his instructions, but the defense argued the questions were too general, and Sullivan later denied further investigation of the juror.
The Legal Stakes: Manifest Necessity
Under Massachusetts law, a mistrial declared over a defendant's objection generally requires "manifest necessity" — a compelling reason to end the trial without a verdict.
The defense argues Sullivan failed to fully explore alternatives, such as questioning the foreperson more thoroughly or removing the holdout, before declaring a mistrial on Sept. 4. The petition also challenges Sullivan's Nov. 9 denial of Clancy's motion to dismiss on double-jeopardy grounds.
Retired judge Jim Barretto told WCVB the filing is over 200 pages and "extraordinarily well written," though he expects a second trial.
What Comes Next
Clancy's attorneys want the Supreme Judicial Court to hear oral arguments before one judge and then refer the matter to the full court. The Plymouth County District Attorney's Office has asked the court not to intervene, per WCVB.
Prosecutors had sought a May trial date, but Sullivan set the retrial for March 29, 2027, and Assistant DA Jennifer Sprague said prosecutors were "ready to pick a jury trial date."
Reddington told Sullivan that prosecutors' insistence on a jury signaled they intend to proceed on first-degree murder indictments. Clancy's first trial centered on her claim of postpartum psychosis.
The Holdout Juror Speaks
WCVB reports that the man identifying himself as the holdout juror has denied in media interviews accusations that he was not following the law, a direct contradiction of the foreperson's notes submitted to the Supreme Judicial Court.
The defense wanted him removed during the trial and Sullivan declined, a decision that ultimately led to the mistrial.