'The Fantasticks' Finally Reaches Broadway — as Boy-Meets-Boy

Tom Jones' gay rewrite of 'The Fantasticks' opened at Broadway's Hayes Theater on Nov. 16, swapping the famous boy-meets-girl plot for Matt and Lewis.

@sharedot

'The Fantasticks' Finally Reaches Broadway — as Boy-Meets-Boy

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Theater
  • Broadway
  • The Fantasticks
  • Tom Jones

Tom Jones' gay rewrite of 'The Fantasticks' opened at Broadway's Hayes Theater on Nov. 16, swapping the famous boy-meets-girl plot for Matt and Lewis.

A 66-Year Wait Ends With Matt and Lewis

Second Stage Theater's production of 'The Fantasticks' opened Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, at Broadway's Hayes Theater, more than six decades after the show's 1960 Off-Broadway debut.

Per Gayety, the production uses Tom Jones' revised book and lyrics with Harvey Schmidt's music, and this time the two young lovers next door are Matt and Lewis — 'boy-meets-girl is now boy-meets-boy,' as New York Theatre Guide's Joe Dziemianowicz put it.

The scheming neighboring fathers who trick their kids into love are now mothers. Christopher Gattelli directs and choreographs the limited run, which Gayety reports ends Feb. 7, 2027.

The Rewrite Took a Decade-Long Side Road First

Gayety reports the same-sex retelling actually premiered at Flint Repertory Theatre in Michigan from June 3 to 19, 2022, before reaching Broadway.

Michael Lluberes, then Flint Rep's producing artistic director, directed that staging and developed the rewrite with Jones, who said transforming the boy and girl into two boys was 'an idea I've had for a long time.'

The version later played Provincetown Playhouse in Massachusetts and Coachella Valley Repertory in Cathedral City, California, before Second Stage picked it up.

Jones died Aug. 11, 2023, at 95 in Sharon, Connecticut, just a year after the queer revision premiered, per Gayety citing The Associated Press.

Critics Split on Whether It's Gay Enough

Reviews are warm but not unanimous.

Gayety notes Adam Feldman gave four stars in Time Out New York, writing that the lovers being boys 'is treated with lovely nonchalance,' while New York Stage Review's Melissa Rose Bernardo, also four stars, called it 'ideologically a big change; dramaturgically surprisingly small.'

Dziemianowicz agreed the sons are 'a total non-issue.' But Gayety reports TheaterMania's David Gordon found the show 'a gay old time that isn't gay enough,' arguing Nathan Levy is 'let down by Jones's revisions' and given 'just Louisa by any other name.'

BroadwayWorld's roundup has David Finkle at three stars finding the romance 'tepid,' while USA Today's Patrick Ryan calls it an 'antidote' to an industry allergic to earnest storytelling.

Cast, Tickets and What Comes Next

Gayety, citing Playbill's roundup, lists Maxim Chlumecky as Matt and Nathan Levy as Lewis — Feldman calls the leads 'fresh-faced, strong-voiced and sweet,' and Gordon calls Chlumecky 'a genuine star with charisma to spare.'

Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer (Mildred Hucklebee) and Ruthie Ann Miles (Bessie Mae Bellomy) play the moms, with Zane Phillips as El Gallo.

Tickets start at $65 per New York Theatre Guide, with $25–$35 rush and $30 under-30 tickets from Second Stage; the show runs 2 hours 5 minutes with one 15-minute intermission.

Separately, Playbill reports Blue Man Group opened its first Broadway engagement, 'A New Holiday Surprise,' at the Lunt-Fontanne on Nov. 17, running through Jan. 3, 2027.

Sources

  1. gayety.com › 'The Fantasticks' on Broadway: Gay Rewrite Reviews, Cast
  2. playbill.com › Reviews: Blue Man Group Brings A New Holiday Surprise to Broadway

More on Theater