Van Gogh Sets $190.4M Sotheby's Record After Nazi Claim Settled
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Art
- Auctions
- Sothebys
- Van Gogh
- Art Market
Châtaigniers en fleurs sold for a record $190.4 million at Sotheby's after a last-minute settlement with heirs of a Jewish owner who sold in 1936.
A Record Sale Hours After a Settlement
Sotheby's New York sold Vincent van Gogh's *Châtaigniers en fleurs* (1890) for $190.4 million with fees on Wednesday, November 18, breaking the artist's previous auction record of $117.2 million set by *Orchard with Cypresses* at Christie's in 2022.
According to The Art Newspaper, the painting hammered at $165 million after nearly five minutes of bidding, going to a bidder in the room — dealer William Acquavella, head of Acquavella Galleries.
The sale cleared only after Sotheby's announced on Tuesday that the Blaquier-Arrieta family had reached an agreement with the legal descendants of Hedwig and Samuel Fischer over the work's Nazi-era provenance, though terms were not disclosed.
The 1936 Sale That Nearly Stopped It
The dispute centered on the painting's ownership history. The Guardian reports that German publisher Samuel Fischer acquired the work in Paris in 1909 and his family sold it in 1936 as Nazi persecution worsened.
His heirs, citing their attorney Gunnar Schnabel, argued the family parted with the painting only because of financial losses suffered under the Nazis, and had called on Sotheby's to prove it was sold at market value.
Town & Country reports the family sold it under pressure and asked Sotheby's to postpone the auction. The Blaquier-Arrieta family bought the painting in 1975 and owned it for more than half a century.
After the sale, Schnabel told The New York Times, per The Guardian, that the fast and fair resolution might encourage other families persecuted in the Nazi era — though he said the auction room carried 'no Champagne atmosphere.'
The Painting's Own Tragic Story
Town & Country notes the work was painted in May 1890 in Auvers-sur-Oise, France, just days after van Gogh arrived there following his release from a psychiatric hospital — depicting tall chestnut trees in pink blossom above a sunny street.
The artist took his own life in the same town two months later, on July 29, 1890.
The painting had been hidden from public view for decades in the collection of Argentine sugar heiress Nelly Arrieta de Blaquier and her husband Carlos Pedro Blaquier, which The Art Newspaper describes as the most valuable collection to come to auction in New York this season.
BBC News reports the result shatters a record set only four years earlier, and that a BBC video captured the moment the price was called at $190.4 million (£144.8 million).
Why the Record Came With a Shrug
The evening's superlatives masked uneven competition. ARTnews reports that both the van Gogh and Cézanne's *Arlequin* hammered below their pre-sale estimates, with only a smattering of bids on the van Gogh — a reversal of expectations for the season's most anticipated paintings.
Sotheby's CEO Charles Stewart told ARTnews he did not think restitution publicity affected bidding, saying, 'I think you have to separate auction heat from auction results.' The Art Newspaper counts just more than one-third of works selling below their low estimates across the night.
ARTnews also quotes Fine Art Group founder Phillip Hoffman, who called Sotheby's guarantees 'just too high' and speculated the house might have lost as much as $50 million on them — a critique Stewart deflected by noting, 'Our estimates weren't shy.'
Cézanne, Cassatt and Douglas Set the Night's Tone
Paul Cézanne's *Arlequin* (1888–90), the last of the artist's four harlequin paintings still in public hands per The Art Newspaper, hammered at $99 million ($111 million with fees) — short of its $120 million estimate and Cézanne's $138 million record — but still the most valuable harlequin ever sold.
Brighter spots followed in the 47-lot Modern Evening sale: ARTnews reports Edward Hopper's *The Martha Mckeen of Wellfleet* took $47.3 million, his second-highest auction price, while Magritte's *L'Ami de l'ordre* made $45 million, a record for a bowler-hat painting.
Aaron Douglas's *Harriet Tubman* (1931) sold for $14.1 million after a seven-minute battle, smashing his previous $600,000 record, with proceeds going to Bennett College, and Mary Cassatt's *Summertime* set a $13.3 million record, nearly doubling her prior mark, per The Art Newspaper.
What the Record Leaves Behind
The two back-to-back sales totaled $777.8 million with fees — the highest single-night figure in Sotheby's history, per ARTnews, edging past the $706 million achieved last November at the Breuer building.
The Blaquier-Arrieta collection still came in at $412 million against a roughly $450 million estimate, and The Art Newspaper reports six of its 12 lots hammered below their low estimates, with a Remedios Varo drawing failing to sell and three lots withdrawn mid-sale.
The Art Newspaper also notes Asian collectors were especially active, buying works by Monet, Cézanne, Degas, Soutine and Schiele.
For the Fischer heirs, the resolution acknowledges, in their words quoted by Sotheby's via The Guardian, 'the suffering of the Fischer family during the Nazi era' — a template other restitution disputes may now follow.
Sources
- artnews.com › Led by Record-Breaking $190.4 M. van Gogh, Sotheby's Impressionist and Modern Art Sales Rake in $777.8 M.
- theartnewspaper.com › Van Gogh painting sells for record $190m at Sotheby's following Nazi loot claims
- theguardian.com › Vincent van Gogh painting auctioned for record $190.4m after dispute over Nazi era sale
- townandcountrymag.com › A Vincent van Gogh Painting Sells for a Record $190.4 Million After Its Owners Settle a Nazi-Era Claim
- bbc.com › Watch: Moment Van Gogh painting sells for record $190.4m (£144.8m)