Radnor and Behrs Take Over Leads in Broadway's Schmigadoon!

TicketNews reports Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs will lead Broadway's Tony-winning Schmigadoon! for a six-week run starting January 19, 2027.

@sharedot

Radnor and Behrs Take Over Leads in Broadway's Schmigadoon!

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Theater
  • Broadway
  • Schmigadoon

TicketNews reports Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs will lead Broadway's Tony-winning Schmigadoon! for a six-week run starting January 19, 2027.

New leads arrive at the Nederlander

According to TicketNews, Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs will take over the leading roles in Broadway's "Schmigadoon!" for a limited six-week engagement beginning January 19, 2027, at the Nederlander Theatre.

Behrs, known for "2 Broke Girls" and "The Neighborhood," will play Melissa Gimble, while Radnor, best known from "How I Met Your Mother," will portray Josh Skinner. Their engagement runs through February 28.

The pair succeeds original Broadway stars Alex Brightman and Sara Chase, who give their final performances on January 17. Brightman and Chase originated their roles in the musical's 2025 world premiere at the Kennedy Center in Washington, D.C., before transferring with the production to Broadway.

A musical on a cast-changing streak

The Nederlander production has already cycled through several changes during its Broadway run, and the swap continues into the new year.

TicketNews reports that Michelle Visage of "RuPaul's Drag Race" is scheduled to make her Broadway debut as Mildred Layton on December 4, replacing Jennifer Simard, with her engagement continuing through January 31 — meaning she will perform alongside Radnor and Behrs at the start of their run.

The current company also includes Ann Harada as Florence Menlove, Brad Oscar as Mayor Menlove, Isabelle McCalla as Emma Tate, Maulik Pancholy as the Reverend Layton and Leprechaun, Max Clayton as Danny Bailey and McKenzie Kurtz as Betsy.

For Behrs, the engagement marks her Broadway debut, while Radnor returns after previous Broadway appearances in "The Graduate" and "Disgraced."

Why the recasting turns heads

The surprise is the timing and the pedigree. According to TicketNews, "Schmigadoon!" received 12 Tony Award nominations in 2026 and won four awards, including Best Musical, Best Book of a Musical, Best Original Score and Best Orchestrations.

The stage adaptation, based on the Apple television series created by Cinco Paul and Ken Daurio, follows two New York doctors who discover a magical town where everyday life unfolds like a Golden Age Broadway musical, with a book, music and lyrics by Paul and direction and choreography by Christopher Gattelli.

Handing those Best Musical-winning roles to a sitcom duo in a limited six-week window is a gamble on star draw over continuity.

Broadway's busy winter and the parade preview

The recast arrives as Broadway heads into a crowded stretch.

News From Broadway reports that nine casts — including "Schmigadoon!" itself — will fold into a single ten-minute medley at the 100th Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade on November 26, arranged by Tom Kitt, with Julianne Hough introducing the segment and coverage from 8:30 a.m. on NBC and Peacock.

The same outlet notes Beth Behrs and Josh Radnor's takeover from January 19 among its latest cast-change announcements.

Theatergoers weighing whether to see Brightman and Chase's final performances in January or the celebrity leads that follow now have a short window either way, with details at schmigadoonbroadway.com.

Sources

  1. ticketnews.com › Josh Radnor and Beth Behrs to Lead Broadway's 'Schmigadoon!' in 2027
  2. news.frombroadway.com › Nine Broadway casts will share one medley at the 100th Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade

More on Theater