Italy Fines Meta $887M Over Facebook Photo Gallery Access

Meta was fined €805 million ($887M) by Italy's data protection authority after Facebook's gallery-suggestions feature ran without user consent.

@sharedot

Italy Fines Meta $887M Over Facebook Photo Gallery Access

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Tech
  • Privacy
  • Meta
  • Regulation

Meta was fined €805 million ($887M) by Italy's data protection authority after Facebook's gallery-suggestions feature ran without user consent.

What Happened

Italy announced an €805 million ($887 million) fine against Meta on Saturday for using photos and videos from Android users' galleries on Facebook without specific consent or adequate disclosure, according to the New York Post.

The Italian Data Protection Authority targeted a feature called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook," saying it violated a European privacy directive incorporated into Italian law.

The directive protects smartphones as part of a person's private sphere and requires "free and informed consent" for such access. The fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, and Meta made no immediate comment.

Why It's Surprising

Investigators found the feature was enabled by default and that Facebook requested gallery access through a single permission covering multiple app functions with different purposes.

FOX 8 News, citing The Hill, reports that the agency called the "generic" nature of the authorization notice a violation of Italian law stemming from the EU's ePrivacy Directive.

That blanket-style permission — bundling distinct purposes into one notice — is exactly what regulators rejected, rather than an obvious misuse of data. The authority also said Meta's "lack of cooperation" with the investigation factored into the penalty.

The Evidence

The Italian Data Protection Authority detailed the remedy: it gave Meta 60 days to make the feature "turned off by default" and adjust the consent notice to include "a separate and specific request for the feature," clearly explaining what it does, that it involves gallery access, and how to disable it.

The New York Post says the fine amounts to approximately 0.47% of Meta's global turnover, and that Meta challenged Italy's jurisdiction.

The Stakes

The fine lands while Meta is already paying heavily for other legal battles.

FOX 8 reports that in August, a coalition of 29 states sued Meta over allegedly addictive design for minors, reaching a $17 billion settlement, and that Texas separately won an over $1 billion payout the same month — bringing the company's total payment sum to around $18 billion.

The outlet also notes that after the November midterm "blue wave," AI safety advocates hope the incoming Congress will back stricter tech regulation. With the feature ordered off by default and fresh consent required, the ruling sets a template for how EU regulators treat bundled app permissions.

Sources

  1. nypost.com › Italy fines Meta $887M over sly access into Android users' photo galleries
  2. fox8.com › Italy fines Meta $887M for accessing users' photos without specific consent

More on Tech