Slate Says Mulaney's 'Sister' Sketch Is SNL's Most Brutal
By @sharedot · · 8 pages
- Comedy
- Snl
- John Mulaney
- Sister Sketch
Slate says John Mulaney's seventh SNL hosting stint delivered the show's most brutal sketch in years: a fake pharma ad skewering eldercare sexism.
'Sister' turns eldercare sexism into a fake pharma ad
According to Slate, the standout of John Mulaney's seventh turn hosting Saturday Night Live was a three-minute digital short titled "Sister" — a mock pharmaceutical ad for a live-in, 24/7 eldercare provider that is "completely free, and also your sister."
Mulaney pitches the product as the alternative to a nursing home or a private health aide costing thousands a week.
Slate calls the sketch the best of the night precisely because it ignored the week's heavy news — the Nvidia CEO scandal that tanked the S&P 500 and the nationwide airport and Microsoft outages — and instead trained its lens on a patriarchal holdout most comedy avoids.
The jokes that made critics wince and laugh
Slate details the sketch's most brutal lines, written by Mikey Day and Streeter Seidell — two men, which Slate notes is surprising.
Per Slate, the ad promises "using Sister won't change your inheritance. You'll still get 50 percent of the house she's currently deep-cleaning," and even Dad's weight comment about Sister becomes a bonding point for Mulaney's "infrequent visits."
Why the skewer landed so hard
For Slate, the sketch's power lies in how specifically it mocks an accepted gender dynamic that everyone knows to be true but few interrogate. As an eldest daughter, the Slate writer says she has braced for this exact future herself, a dread also explored in films like American Fiction.
Slate argues the laughter proves men's weaponized incompetence is now being noticed by men themselves — Day and Seidell wrote it — and by everyone watching. Whether any of these brothers actually change the dynamic, Slate concludes, may be another story entirely.
The Woodstock bit viewers called the best ever
BuzzFeed reports another standout sketch imagined 1969 Woodstock as the moment the American dream died, with Mulaney's hippie proposing, "When we get older, I think we should buy as many houses as we can and just, like, have them," plus a pivot to Reagan-era money worship and "Just Say No" parenting around 1985.
BuzzFeed says the sketch racked up nearly 1 million YouTube views in one day, with one X user calling it "EASILY the most accurate SNL skit in years" and another "the best SNL skit of all time because it told the freaking truth."
Video: Bridgers' skull reveal stopped the show
Watch on YouTube · Saturday Night Live · 4:37
Variety reports Phoebe Bridgers returned to SNL as a solo musical guest for the first time since 2021 and performed "Still Standing," a song about her father's death, only for UV black lights to reveal skull makeup hidden under her face makeup for the entire show — a practical effect, not digital.
Variety argues the transformation emotionally elevated one of the best pop songs ever written about death, pairing the visual with lyrics about grieving someone who caused grief.
What got cut, and why the night mattered
Stereogum reports the show skipped its traditional "10 to one" final slot, and the cut-for-time sketch — Mulaney's Pope meeting James Austin Johnson's defiantly unreadable Bob Dylan, riffing on Dylan's real meeting with Pope Leo XIV — surfaced online afterward.
Meanwhile, Slate says Mulaney closed with his traditional New York musical medley, this time a "Little Park of Horrors" carriage-horse revue lampooning Mayor Zohran Mamdani's promised carriage-horse ban.
For Slate, the episode proved Mulaney remains one of SNL's most capable captains: delighting you one second, distilling a complex social truth the next.
Sources
- slate.com › SNL Just Aired Its Best—and Most Brutal—Sketch in a Long Time
- buzzfeed.com › This "SNL" Woodstock Sketch Is Being Hailed As The Best In Show History
- variety.com › Phoebe Bridgers' Skeletal Transformation on 'SNL' Wasn't Just a Startling Special Effect
- stereogum.com › Bob Dylan Meets The Pope In Cut-For-Time SNL Sketch