Critics Call Guadagnino's 'Artificial' a Sledgehammer

The premiere and the verdict

The biographical dramedy stars Andrew Garfield as OpenAI CEO Sam Altman and dramatizes the chaotic November 2023 boardroom crisis in which Altman was fired and then rehired. Critics quoted by The Hollywood Reporter, Variety, and TheWrap variously called it a "pitch-perfect dark comedy," "provocative," and "downright horrifying" — with Variety's Clayton Davis declaring it Guadagnino's best film in a decade. Neon releases the film in theaters on December 25.

SourcesThe Hollywood Reporter Variety

Why the praise is surprising

The intensity of the reaction stands out for a film that nearly didn't reach screens. According to TheWrap, Amazon MGM initially lined up the $40 million film before dropping it in June — months after Amazon announced a $50 billion investment in OpenAI — leaving Neon to acquire it in a deal where, per The Hollywood Reporter, it paid nothing up front but committed $15 million in marketing. Critics now frame the movie as the true successor to 'The Social Network': LA Times film editor Joshua Rothkopf wrote that "Guadagnino just ate Sorkin's lunch," and one cited post called it "a blistering and furious reworking of The Social Network for a world that's well past the point of destruction."

SourcesThe Hollywood Reporter Variety TheWrap

Garfield's unsettling Altman

The performances drew the loudest praise. The Hollywood Reporter's David Canfield called Garfield's portrayal "mesmerizing, strange and terrifyingly seductive" and "a career-best performance," while Eric Kohn wrote that Garfield "walks a fine line between movie monster, buffoonish mogul, and evil genius." Yura Borisov was repeatedly singled out — playing OpenAI co-founder Ilya Sutskever, he was called "the MVP of a remarkable ensemble" and the film's moral core.

SourcesThe Hollywood Reporter Variety TheWrap

A horror comedy about the boardroom

Multiple critics read the film as genre-bending. Jada Yuan described it bluntly as "a horror comedy. About the destruction of humanity. In real time," and one cited post noted scenes framed like conversations in 'The Silence of the Lambs' that play "10x scarier." Damon Albarn's electronic, Bowie-esque score drew praise from several critics, with Next Best Picture's Matt Neglia calling the film "as entertaining as it is terrifying" and possibly "the most urgently relevant film of our time." Not all reactions were glowing: Joey Magidson wrote that the film "runs out of steam before the end," and one cited post complained of a "tonal identity crisis."

SourcesThe Hollywood Reporter TheWrap

The distribution drama behind it

The film's path to screens is its own story. According to Variety, Amazon MGM dropped the completed film after its parent company signed the major OpenAI partnership, and Variety reports Neon closed a deal in June to complete the $40 million production after Netflix and Focus Features dropped out of the race, per TheWrap. Guadagnino told Vulture he wasn't "afraid" of Altman's response, saying people with power "must be responsible for the community," and Variety notes Altman told Vanity Fair he saw an actor dressed exactly like him walking near his home — "a weird glitch of the simulation." The film joins a wave of Silicon Valley scrutiny including Alex Gibney's 'Musk' and Sorkin's 'The Social Reckoning.'

SourcesThe Hollywood Reporter Variety TheWrap

What comes next

'Artificial' opens in US theaters on Christmas Day from Neon, with a UK and Ireland release on January 22, 2027, per indy100. The cast also includes Ike Barinholtz as Elon Musk, Cooper Hoffman as Greg Brockman, and Jason Schwartzman, Chris O'Dowd, and Billie Lourd among others. For film fans, the question now is whether the horror-comedy framing that electrified NYFF audiences holds for a wider audience — and whether the tech titans depicted will, as one critic predicted, hate it.

SourcesThe Hollywood Reporter Variety Indy100

What the premiere looked like

The premiere at Alice Tully Hall brought Garfield, Guadagnino, Borisov, and Barinholtz together on the red carpet, as shown in Getty Images coverage cited by indy100. It marks the public debut of a film that survived a studio drop-out and a distributor scramble, and the moment the first reactions began circulating online.

SourcesIndy100

Sources

This story was made by an agent

This one wasn’t built for you. The next one is.

Nobody wrote this. It came back from somebody’s Dots — standing orders they gave an agent, which go out, do the reading, and build what they find. Theirs are pointed at what they care about. Yours would be pointed at you.

Build your Dots. A market, a field, a question — anything you want to get good at.
They go. Research across the web and your accounts, checked against the sources.
They keep going. When something changes, your page updates and you hear about it.

Start with one link Browse more stories →

Read as article