Nonbinary Runners Sue Philly Marathon Over Elite Division Ban

Three nonbinary athletes sued the Philadelphia Marathon, saying its elite divisions exclude them.

@sharedot

Nonbinary Runners Sue Philly Marathon Over Elite Division Ban

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Fitness
  • Running
  • Philadelphia Marathon
  • Nonbinary Athletes

Three nonbinary athletes sued the Philadelphia Marathon, saying its elite divisions exclude them.

What happened: a lawsuit days before race weekend

Three nonbinary runners — Winter Parts, Reed Williams, and Miche Palmer — sued the City of Philadelphia and race director Kathleen Titus in Common Pleas Court on Tuesday, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer.

The suit argues the Philadelphia Marathon and half marathon violate the city's Fair Practices Ordinance, which specifically prohibits discrimination on the basis of gender identity, by refusing to offer a nonbinary registration option in the professional divisions.

Athletes can register as nonbinary in the open division, but must select male or female to compete for larger cash prizes, elite accommodations, and prestige. The suit asks a judge to find the city violated the ordinance, order the race to end the exclusion, and award damages.

Why it's surprising: inclusion exists, but only partly

The surprise is how partial the marathon's inclusion is.

Philadelphia opened nonbinary registration in the open division back in 2022 — after years of advocacy from local LGBTQ+ run clubs Queer Run and Lez Run — and added equal prize money for nonprofessional nonbinary winners in 2024, when nearly 120 nonbinary runners participated across the weekend.

Yet the professional division still requires male or female registration, and the Philadelphia Gay News reports there is also no open division for wheelchair competitors, leaving nonbinary wheelchair racers to join a binary category or skip the race.

Organizers say the professional policy follows USA Track & Field guidance, and USATF offers no nonbinary inclusion guidance at the elite level.

The evidence: prize gaps and misgendering on course

The complaint details what runners say they lost. According to the Inquirer, Reed Williams placed first in the nonbinary open division in 2024 and won $4,000 — while professional division winners took $10,000.

Winter Parts finished as the first nonbinary runner in the open division in 2022 and received nothing.

The suit also describes misgendering: Parts was directed into binary finish-line corridors in 2022 and had to choose how to be misgendered, and all nonbinary runners were assigned male or female in published results.

The Philadelphia Gay News adds that Williams witnessed officials sorting runners by perceived gender at the 2023 finish line, and says elite perks like personal water bottles, waived fees, and sheltered waiting areas carry real performance advantages.

The stakes: a pathway to elite running

Advocates frame the case as bigger than one race.

Josh Fernandez, president and executive director of Queer Run, told the Philadelphia Gay News that representation without real opportunities only goes so far, asking how nonbinary athletes can reach professional status in running if they cannot compete professionally in the first place.

A petition has gathered more than 900 local signatures, and advocates say they pursued a Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations complaint in July 2025 before filing suit.

Palmer is running this year despite the dispute, telling the paper it feels like going into a situation where they are only partly welcome, while Parts cheers from the sideline. A Law Department spokesperson declined to comment, per the Inquirer.

Sources

  1. inquirer.com › Philly Marathon discriminates by not allowing nonbinary runners in pro division, lawsuit says
  2. epgn.com › Nonbinary runners file lawsuit against City of Philadelphia days before annual marathon

More on Fitness