Vulcan Failure Clears BE-4 Engines; Fuel Supply Blamed

ULA's update says low booster thrust came from inadequate fuel supply to the BE-4 engines, not the engines themselves — a reprieve for Blue Origin.

@sharedot

Vulcan Failure Clears BE-4 Engines; Fuel Supply Blamed

By @sharedot · · 7 pages

  • Space
  • Rocket Launches
  • Ula Vulcan

ULA's update says low booster thrust came from inadequate fuel supply to the BE-4 engines, not the engines themselves — a reprieve for Blue Origin.

The new finding: fuel supply, not engines

In its Nov. 18 update, ULA narrowed the cause of Sunday's Vulcan Centaur failure: 'While work remains to determine cause, preliminary indications are that the low booster thrust was the result of inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines, not from the performance of the engines.'

That shifts suspicion away from the engines and toward how the vehicle delivered propellant to them. ULA said work remains to determine the ultimate cause, so the finding is preliminary rather than final.

A reprieve for Blue Origin's BE-4

The finding is good news for Blue Origin, which builds the BE-4.

Blue Origin issued its own statement on Wednesday, saying that together with ULA it identified that the low booster thrust resulted from inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle, not engine performance — a rare piece of good news while New Glenn remains grounded after a May test explosion.

What performed well on the flight

ULA had already reported that Vulcan's six solid rocket boosters and its Centaur V upper stage, which uses the RL-10 engine, appeared to perform normally on Sunday, and further analysis is firming up that conclusion.

The problem is that the upper stage could not make up for the performance lost in the first stage, so the rocket failed to reach orbit.

Notably, the SRB nozzles — the source of an earlier Vulcan problem — worked this time after a redesign fix by ULA and Northrop Grumman following burn-throughs on the second and fourth flights.

The stakes: Amazon's constellation and national security

The Nov. 15 launch destroyed 40 satellites for Amazon's Leo broadband network, which had roughly 400 satellites in orbit beforehand out of more than 3,200 planned, according to mlq.ai.

The flight was also meant to help return Vulcan to the Space Force's National Security Space Launch program; mlq.ai reports the service had grounded the rocket for those missions in late February and reassigned six missions to SpaceX by Oct. 1.

According to mlq.ai, Ars Technica reports the rocket will be offline for several months.

What comes next under FAA oversight

ULA is leading the anomaly investigation under Federal Aviation Administration oversight, and the FAA must approve its final report and any corrective actions before Vulcan returns to flight. ULA has not given a return-to-flight date.

The rocket has a short but troubled history: it debuted in January 2024 and has now experienced issues on three of its five flights, though Sunday's was the only one that ended in failure.

After the February SRB issue it was grounded about nine months, so the length of this new grounding will depend on what the investigation finds.

Sources

  1. space.com › ULA traces Vulcan Centaur rocket failure to 'inadequate fuel supply' to 1st-stage engines
  2. mlq.ai › ULA says early data point to inadequate fuel supply, not the BE-4 engines, in the Vulcan failure

More on Space