ULA Points to First-Stage Booster in Vulcan Failure

ULA's first investigation update blames low first-stage booster performance just after liftoff for Vulcan's failure, the company's first in 30 years.

@sharedot

ULA Points to First-Stage Booster in Vulcan Failure

By @sharedot · · 6 pages

  • Space
  • Ula
  • Vulcan Centaur
  • Amazon Leo
  • Blue Origin

ULA's first investigation update blames low first-stage booster performance just after liftoff for Vulcan's failure, the company's first in 30 years.

First failure in ULA's 30-year history

Two days after the Nov. 15 loss of 40 Amazon Leo satellites, ULA issued its first substantive update on the mishap, and the findings mark an unwanted first: Space Policy Online reports this was the first launch failure in the company's 30-year history.

ULA says early indications point to low first-stage booster performance just after liftoff, causing stage separation at low altitude and below the velocity needed to reach orbit. Telemetry and mission were lost about 10 minutes into flight.

The FAA is overseeing the ULA-led investigation and must approve the final report and corrective actions.

The BE-4 question now hangs over two rockets

The suspect first stage is powered by two Blue Origin BE-4 methalox engines, and the SRB nozzles that plagued earlier flights appear exonerated.

ULA stated that all indications are the six Northrop Grumman solid rocket boosters performed nominally following nozzle improvements, and that the Centaur V upper stage and its RL-10 engines started nominally but could not recover from the performance loss.

According to Space Policy Online, a BE-4 main oxidizer valve was traced to May's New Glenn pad explosion, and valve changes were made across BE-4s including these. ULA has not identified the exact booster problem.

A grounded rocket in a launch crunch

The stakes extend far beyond one mission. According to the Orlando Sentinel, the failure was the first in 134 ULA flights since 2006, and ULA holds more than two dozen national security task orders plus 38 contracted Amazon Leo launches.

Florida Today reports the Space Coast's launch rate has dwindled since SpaceX moved Starlink missions to Vandenberg, leaving the industry with too few heavy rockets.

What comes next

ULA says it is still gathering data and wants to avoid speculation until the investigation is complete, pledging to return to flight as safely and quickly as it can.

Blue Origin confirmed it is working closely with ULA on the root cause, per Florida Today, and the finding could slow New Glenn's own comeback, which company officials target for early January after the May test-stand explosion.

The Centaur V upper stage's nominal performance is a small bright spot for NASA, which plans to integrate it into the SLS for Artemis crewed moon missions. Photographers at the Cape watched a picture-perfect liftoff, unaware anything was wrong until ULA's 'total loss of mission' message arrived.

Sources

  1. space.com › ULA lost a Vulcan Centaur rocket 10 minutes after launch — but the failure began just after liftoff
  2. spacepolicyonline.com › ULA Investigating Low Booster Performance in Vulcan Launch Failure
  3. orlandosentinel.com › Main booster could be source of Vulcan launch failure, ULA says
  4. coralspringsflnews.com › 'Star-crossed': ULA Vulcan rocket failure rattles U.S. space industry

More on Space