Fifth Circuit Rules Pandemic House Proxy Voting Unconstitutional
By @sharedot · · 6 pages
- Politics
- Congress
- Fifth Circuit
- Proxy Voting
The en banc Fifth Circuit ruled the House's COVID-era proxy voting unconstitutional, voiding the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act in Texas.
A pandemic workaround struck down
A full, en banc Fifth Circuit ruled in *Texas v.
Blanche* that the House of Representatives' COVID-era proxy voting rule violated the Constitution's Quorum Clause, holding that lawmakers unconstitutionally passed the fiscal 2023 Consolidated Appropriations Act when hundreds of absent members were counted as "present" by proxy.
Judge Cory Wilson, a Donald Trump appointee, wrote for the majority that the clause's "text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application" require members to be physically present, and that "'proxy presence' does not count."
The practical effect is that the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, a law requiring accommodations for pregnant employees, can no longer be enforced against Texas.
Why the ruling lands so hard
The vote at issue shows how much rode on the rule: 431 members voted on the $1.7 trillion omnibus on December 23, 2022, but only 205 cast votes in person while 226 were cast by proxy — so fewer than a majority of the House's 435 members were physically on the floor.
Other federal courts had rejected challenges to proxy voting when it was adopted, finding the suits foreclosed by the Speech or Debate Clause, which shields members from lawsuits over legislative acts.
The en banc court broke with that trend by accepting Texas's challenge on Quorum Clause grounds and rejecting the government's enrolled-bill defense.
Dissenters warn of a slippery slope
Reason's Volokh Conspiracy, where Eugene Volokh posted the opinions, notes the majority's rationale would supply a basis for invalidating the rest of the omnibus, from the government-device TikTok ban to the Electoral Count Reform Act, and doubts the ruling will survive Supreme Court review.
Reason also flags that the new Texas attorney general may choose not to press the case.
What comes next
Bloomberg Law News reports the decision is certain to be appealed to the US Supreme Court, and the ruling could open the door to new challenges against other laws enacted during the Biden administration through proxy votes.
Timing adds political wrinkle: the ruling came just after a Democrat won the Texas attorney general race, meaning Republicans will no longer control the office that generated the challenge starting in January.
Bloomberg Law News also notes the court framed its holding narrowly, applying it only to Texas's challenge to the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, leaving the broader fate of proxy-voting legislation to higher courts.